Skip to main content

Part 2: gain, radiation patterns and polarization

The question: Is an 8 dBi antenna better than a 3 dBi antenna?

Not always. The larger number tells you that the antenna is more effective in its favored direction relative to a standard reference—not that it reaches every direction farther or creates more transmitter power.

Gain is about where the energy goes​

Imagine a lamp. A bare bulb spreads light across the room. A reflector can concentrate light in a narrower area, making that area brighter without increasing the bulb's electrical power.

Antennas work differently from light reflectors in the details, but the analogy is helpful: higher directional gain concentrates radiation and receive sensitivity in favored directions. There is a tradeoff somewhere else in the pattern.

A real antenna's shape creates a three-dimensional . An outdoor “omnidirectional” vertical is normally intended to cover compass directions around the horizon, but its radiation varies with elevation—up or down—and may have weaker directions or nulls.

Conceptual radiation patterns: a broad vertical-antenna pattern, a flatter higher-gain vertical-antenna pattern, and a focused directional antenna beam.

The drawings are conceptual, not measured plots of any commercial antenna. An actual pattern depends on its design, frequency, mounting and surroundings.

What do dB, dBi and dBd mean?​

  • dB (decibels): a ratio between two power levels. By itself it does not tell you the reference.
  • dBi: gain referenced to an ideal, lossless , a mathematical antenna that radiates equally in every direction.
  • dBd: gain referenced to a half-wave under comparable conditions.
  • dBm: an absolute power level relative to one milliwatt. It is not an antenna gain rating.

For conventional free-space comparisons, 0 dBd = approximately 2.15 dBi. Therefore, a claimed 5 dBd is approximately 7.15 dBi—not because the antenna changed, but because the reference changed.

What does “3 dB” represent?​

For power ratios, an increase of 3 dB is approximately twice the power in the direction being compared. An increase of 6 dB is approximately four times the power. A decrease of 3 dB is approximately half the power.

That is not the same thing as twice the communication range. Range depends on terrain, antenna heights and patterns, signal-to-noise ratio, interference, radio sensitivity, link margin and propagation.

Vertical pattern versus horizontal pattern​

Antenna diagrams often show two views:

ViewWhat it showsWhy it matters
Azimuth (horizontal)Relative response as you move around the antenna at the same elevationCoverage in different compass directions
Elevation (vertical)Relative response as the destination angle moves up or downCoverage to valleys, nearby ground users, hills and distant horizons

A common mistake is seeing a circular plot and concluding the antenna must radiate equally in every direction. It might have deep nulls while remaining nearly round in azimuth.

A taller, higher-gain collinear may flatten its main elevation lobe. That can help a long, roughly level path, yet perform less well for users steeply uphill or downhill. Some antenna patterns also produce multiple elevation lobes and nulls, and mounting close to metal can distort the pattern.

Omnidirectional and directional antennas​

Omni vertical: often the default when you need to reach users in many compass directions. But you still need to check elevation coverage, gain data and polarization.

Directional antenna: such as a Yagi or panel. Often a better choice for a known remote site with a fixed bearing. It deliberately trades coverage in other directions for greater response toward the target.

For a mesh node serving neighbors in all directions, a directional antenna may leave nearby users worse off. For a fixed link across a ridge, a properly aimed directional antenna may outperform a higher-gain omni.

Polarization: the direction of the electric field​

Antenna is related to the orientation of its radiated electric field. Common simple antennas are vertically or horizontally polarized. Other designs use circular polarization.

Two linearly polarized antennas with the same orientation generally couple best in an unobstructed link. Turning one antenna sideways relative to the other can produce a significant mismatch, though reflections and imperfect polarization change the result in the real world.

Practical example: If a handheld and a fixed 915 MHz antenna are both designed for vertical polarization, keep the handheld upright for comparison tests. Rotation matters. An antenna inside a plastic case may not have an obvious orientation—check its design.

The gain number on a shopping page is not enough​

Before treating a quoted number as meaningful, ask:

  1. Is it dBi or dBd? Is there a verified measurement?
  2. At what frequency? A peak near one end of the band may not apply where you operate.
  3. What is the elevation pattern? Will it reach a nearby valley or another high tower?
  4. Is it an honest measured or modeled pattern? A generic product photo doesn't establish gain.
  5. Is the value for the antenna alone? A cable-equipped antenna assembly has additional loss.
  6. What's the efficiency? An extremely compact or poorly constructed antenna may waste power despite an attractive SWR reading.

A measurement with a known source is more useful than an unverified “12 dBi long range” claim.

Worked example: a hilltop repeater​

You install a 3 dBi vertical on a high ridge. The users you want to reach are both distant farms near the same elevation and hikers on a steep trail below the ridge.

A replacement antenna claims 9 dBi. It may improve the near-horizontal farm links if its real elevation pattern favors them. But the hikers are at a much steeper angle; their received signal may get weaker.

What would you do? Look for the maker's elevation pattern, compare real receiver reports at several locations, and change one variable at a time. More gain is not automatically the answer.

Sources​

Next: Part 3 — Feedline, Impedance, SWR and Loss.